Final Words

In light of our final testing, it is very important to mention that we did not shut down the system and let the card cool down between each test. It is therefore possible that we didn't see the highest potential performance gains we could have from each game. Ideally we would have done this, but we've only had these drivers for a day, and we didn't know the extent to which continued use would affect the cards performance. Of course, this isn't all bad.

The fact that this card overclocks itself based on temperature allows at lot of room for differentiation between different R360 based products. The type of cooling card makers decide to strap on these chips will directly affect how much performance a user can get out of the overdrive feature. Since this doesn't involve doing things like tweaking core and memory clock speeds at the OEM side, more manufacturers can offer cards that have the performance of overclocking with the rock solid stability ATI’s overdrive feature offers. All that's necessary for more consistent performance gains is a better cooling solution.

Of course, we don't know how intensive cooling will affect maximum performance as we don't know the upper limit of ATI’s automatic clock settings.

Overall, these drivers offer some very good UI enhancements, and the overdrive feature does provide tangible speed improvements, and hopefully their VPU Recovery feature will save some people the trouble of blindly rebooting their systems when they lose video. Unfortunately, we didn't see the image quality fixes for TRAOD and Neverwinter Nights that we wanted. Hopefully ATI will not stand by and hope enough people think NVIDIA’s image quality is poor enough that the issue with their own product can go ignored.

Of course, the speed gains from this driver release are not astronomical, but when we add these small gains to the gains already seen in the 9800XT, we can definitely say that this is a solid, well rounded, fall refresh product from ATI. We applaud ATI for trying to go in new directions to enhance performance, and we hope to see plenty of cards from their partners that take advantage of the opportunity presented to them by the XT line. Even so, we are still standing behind our wait and see recommendation with respect to purchasing a card intended for use with the coming DX9 games.

Turning up the Heat
Comments Locked

62 Comments

View All Comments

  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    #31 was a reply to # 28.
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    are you telling me that your going to play HL2 , in DX8 at 640x800 on your Fx ? to get decent framerates ?


  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    Nice of you to warn us ahead of time #8.
    It does take one to know one.
    So in your esteemed opinion, what are all the current GF FX card owners to do?
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    i am a little disappointed with the overdrive feature as well...i was all exicted too about the possibilities...and certainly expecting more than just a 1.5fps difference :(

  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    #26 said: ""TombRaider AOD , the only DX9 game benchmarked is 3 1/2 times faster than Nvidia.
    ATI 42 fps , Nvidia 12 fps.

    WoooW.
    Imagine HL2.""

    Do0d, TRAOD has nothing to do with HL2. Also, NV is playable at lower resolutions than 16x12. And any card will fly with PS2.0 off...
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    ...I'm honestly struggling to work out why CM hyped these up as the best Catalysts ever. We knew these weren't going to be performance drivers, but the new features are gimmicky (overdrive/smartshader) or not as good as they should be (game profiles, but you have to manually switch them, bah!). Oh well, some bug fixes are at least nice.

    A somewhat disappointed 9800 Pro'er.
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    TombRaider AOD , the only DX9 game benchmarked is 3 1/2 times faster than Nvidia.
    ATI 42 fps , Nvidia 12 fps.

    WoooW.
    Imagine HL2.

    I'm impressed, If Cat 3.8 bring more stability, that should be good enough for ATI owners.

    a Gforce2 mx owner.
  • AgaBooga - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    #24, ATI would have had to implement special temperature measuring devices. I wonder how the bios flashing will respond to this...
  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    sucks like 0.1% of gamers or market have the 9800TX why not do it with 9700pro or 9800pro


    just a though ...............




  • Anonymous User - Wednesday, October 8, 2003 - link

    #20,

    You got your roman numerals backwards.
    VIII is 8
    IX is 9
    X is 10
    XI is 11
    XII is 12
    XIII is 13
    XIV is 14 and so on

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now